It Is What It Is
NEED TO KNOW
Follow WEEI.com football writer Christopher Price at twitter.com/cpriceNFL. In addition, get the latest WEEI.com updates at twitter.com/WEEI.
A WEEI.com Patriots Blog
WEEI.com Blog Network

Opinion: Blame Roger Goodell, owners for replacement disaster

09.24.12 at 1:46 am ET
By

Greed.

Roger Goodell has been NFL commissioner since 2006. (AP)

NFL commissioner Roger Goodell has come under fire for his handling of the referee situation. (AP)

That’s the only reason you, me and 15 million others had to watch replacement officials do everything possible to screw up what should have been a terrific football game on Sunday night.

This is only about billionaire owners not wanting to lose a fight to referees, plain and simple. Follow the money and all that. We can knock Roger Goodell all day about this — and plenty of it is justified, to be sure — but if the owners told Goodell tomorrow to make a deal, Goodell would make a deal.

But that’s not going to happen. As hideous as the replacement officials were on Sunday night — players fighting after plays with no flags thrown, 24 accepted penalties for 215 yards and 13 first downs, botched holding and pass interference calls, utterly and completely overwhelmed refs who seemingly were intimidated by coaches and players, total amateur hour — it won’t change what really matters to Goodell and the owners.

Ratings aren’t going anywhere, which means money for the networks, which will eventually mean more money for the NFL. We know now that player safety and the integrity of the game don’t mean nearly as much as making every last dollar of profit. And no one is going to stop watching games and paying for Sunday Ticket and gambling on games and playing fantasy football. From a strictly financial perspective, where is the motivation to make a deal with the refs?

I get that it’s a business, I really do. No problem there. But don’t try, as Goodell as done over the last couple of years, to sell me on the idea that player safety is paramount. It’s not. Concussions only landed on Goodell’s radar because of lawsuits. Fear of losing money was the motivation. And now the chance to save some money is why you’ve got Division 3 officials looking like Division 3 officials every Sunday. Has “protecting the shield” ever seemed more disingenuous than it did on Sunday night?

Don’t blame the replacement officials, either. It’s not their fault that owners want to make the very best deal possible — quality of the product be damned — or that the regular officials want to continue their defined-benefit pension plan (the league wants to put a freeze on that plan and shift them over to a 401(k)).

It’s not their fault that they aren’t good enough. It’s not their fault that they were put in a position to only fail. It’s not their fault, really, that the players and coaches have less than no respect for their authority or ability (Bill Belichick and John Harbaugh had a duel of disgust with the refs on Sunday night).

It’s never going to work. It’s not going to get better, either. The ineptitude you witnessed on Sunday night — against both teams — won’t be enough to trigger a change in philosophy from the owners and Goodell. Nope. Here’s what you’ll need: A serious injury to a superstar or a couple of influential owners breaking ranks. Short of that — assuming the regular refs don’t give in — you’ll see some of these guys botching calls at the Super Bowl next February.

Let’s be very clear about this: The refs made some terrible calls against the Patriots on Sunday — a holding call against Brandon Spikes, a pass interference against Jerod Mayo, a Julian Edelman catch wiped out by a bogus offensive PI call — but they also applied their brand of suckage against the Ravens. And the refs had nothing to do with Kyle Arrington and McCourty struggling to catch easy interceptions, or Rob Gronkowski catching two passes (just three targets, or one more than Kellen Winslow and as many as Deion Branch) or Danny Woodhead getting 15 carries or Ray Rice rushing for 101 yards or Flacco doing whatever he wanted in the final three quarters.

The referees didn’t cost the Patriots the game. I’ll buy that. But that isn’t the point. How are we supposed to take the games seriously if the commissioner doesn’t even care, if he allows that disgrace to occur under his watch?

The biggest sport in America — by a lot — is, right now, a joke. The best players and coaches in the world are being officiated by folks in way over their heads. Clueless and powerless. And it shows and it shows often and we saw the worst to date on Sunday night.

But we were watching and we’ll be watching next Sunday and every Sunday after that. And for Goodell and his owners, that’s all that matters.

Read More: replacement officials, roger goodell, Print  |  Bark It Up!  |  Digg It
  • Anonymous

    I’m finished with MNF. 

  • Tabdouch

    I’m done I will no longer watch this circus!! The seahawks was handed the game they did not win and they should be ashamed to celebrate this as a win!!! Jennings clearly had the ball!!! The NFL makes a ton of money and if you can’t pay the correct officials to make sure the correct teams win then you deserve this circus but my family and friends will not watch! We have college football we don’t need this crap

  • Thimasdorian

    Just saw Green Bay Seattle game…shame on the commissioner…total embarrassment For the NFL. The product is now garbage!

  • SF

    It’s time to get the bugs worked out and the “REAL’ refs back to work.I watched the Sunday night game and thought I was watching a rugby scrum most of the time …..without one flag and there were several calls tonight …..especially on the last play…….that a high school ref would have made better……

  • Dclearry555

    Seattle & Green Bay game….NFL is now soccer. Way to go commissioner.

  • Shane_44

    NFL Fan No More!!!! Watched pro football since 1966 but no more. They (the NFL) have no regard for the fans or they wouldn’t allow these replacement refs to continue. Goodell gets credit for success, in my view this is squarely his fault, I do blame Goodell…..Think I will start watching pro wrestling. until fans turn our back on the game this will only continue.

  • Mjrsullivan

    I’m seriously considering giving up my season tickets.  Not only was Monday’s game terribly officiated, but then the NFL regulars review the last call and don’t reverse it.  What a joke!  Why have replay?  Two very clear offensive interference calls on the last drive then culminated by the last play.  Certainly we can point to many other games in the 3 weeks of this early season and agree the refs just don’t have control of the game. 

    Now, with that said I personally do not agree with what the NFL officials and there selfish demands. 

  • RLAR64

    Boycott the NFL advertiser’s products!  BOYCOTT THE NFL SPONSOR’S PRODUCTS UNTIL THEY STOP RIPPING US OFF WITH FAKE REFS!!!! 
     BOYCOTT THE NFL 
    SPONSOR’S  PRODUCTS UNTIL THEY STOP RIPPING US OFF WITH FAKE REFS!!!! AND WRITE THE 
    SPONSOR’S TO LET THEM KNOW YOUR DONE WITH THEM UNTIL THE REAL REFS RETURN!!

  • KC

    I agree with you, NFL Owners are treating the refs like they are commodities! As much as they claim they will “do ANYTHING to protect the shield”, this debacle with the refs is eroding the integrity of the game. They are a money generating machine, as long as they have ratings, sell advertising, stadium seats, licensed NFL gear and the other swag that comes from this great brand it simply doesn’t matter. 
    Fans need to take some action, we are insulted by their arrogance! If not a boycott, an open letter with millions of fans signatures could be in order. Perhaps calling for an organized boycott of all things football including sponsors on a certain date if they don’t have the decency and respect to resolve.

  • Bleujayone

    I don’t get this. Referees are one of the least expensive parts of the game- especially when you realize their importance to the overall product quality.  They don’t even get the dignity of being full-time employees.  Personally, I think the refs should be paid as full-timers and in their off hours they should be brushing up on their game calling by reviewing their past efforts , be constantly tested on the rulebook and, getting and staying in physical shape just as the players do.  Whatever the refs are asking for, give it to them. I cannot imagine it will break anyone’s bank. These last few weeks have proven that they are not so easily replaced. While the regulars may not be perfect (they are only human), it is quite clear their replacements are completely lost and the NFL brand is suffering for it.

  • Dave

    Concur with the first word of this article.  It’s pretty clear.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/SOR6IGIWGBDIWZJQFYBUGIG7RQ Michael Hicks

    Monday night, you mean Monday night was the worst to date…so far.

  • Katiestyle7

    We need to hurt the $$$ stream to make this stop!!!
    As for the Official 2012 Sponsors who are paying into this travesty, I apologize that you are going to be the ones as innocently hurt as our teams and players. I love and use your products
    Nike, Home Depot, Procter Gamble/Tide, Pepsi, Verizon, Anheuser-Bush/Bud Light, Marriott Hotels/Courtyard Inn, Visa, Papa John’s, FedEx, General Motors, Gatorade, and I am certain this is not what you signed up for. As of today though, for the sake of the safety of our players, the integrity of the game, and the fact I will not condone or continue to support anything associated with this illegitimate mirage the NFL is placing before us, I QUIT ALL THINGS NFL FOOTBALL until notice of the return of our official referees.

  • POOR NFL

    Well here is my 2 cents. Our family watches football whenever football is on. We pretty much only carry satellite service to be able to get NFL Sunday ticket. The officiating has been horrible and frustrating to watch this season. Flags thrown for no reason, blows to the head with no flags thrown, it’s just sad. I’m not a Packers or Seahawks fan, but after that game last night I called Directv and cancelled my subscription. I know I’m only one person, but consider me on strike too NFL!!!!!

  • DellSPS

    I’m from New Orleans…I’m not watching any more games. Yeah, the Saints stink right now but I can’t get my football intelligence battered any more….it feels like Pro Wrestling, Sorry to the GB fans. We ALL deserve better. No matter the team we support.  Are there any Seattle fans out there willing to admit that was BS? I’d hate to “win” that way.

  • James

    Evidently, Ravens fans don’t mind winning that way.

  • Mazz

    DId Michael Felger ghost-write this?

  • Ronlondon7

    Roger Goodell is a Wuss and should be replaced…………………….

  • pfin

    The owners core beliefs are aligned with the GOP in that they do not want to give pensions and would rather the refs pay for their own 401ks.  They have made a mockery of the game in order to reaffirm their politics and ideology.  Give the refs pensions and give us back our game. 

Latest on Twitter

2013 PATRIOTS DRAFT PICKS

2013 NFL DRAFT

Patriots Headlines
NFL Headlines
Tips & Feedback

Verify