|Bill Polian says he had a first-round grade on Tom Brady. He’s almost certainly lying||03.07.17 at 3:55 pm ET|
Maybe former Colts general manager Bill Polian did have a first-round grade on Tom Brady before the 2000 NFL Draft. But all discernible evidence says otherwise.
In an interview this week at the NFL Scouting Combine, Polian said he was “really high on Brady.” This statement correlates with comments he made to Sports Illustrated in 2015, when he was asked about which quarterbacks he would’ve drafted if Peyton Manning weren’t on the Colts.
“Well, Roethlisberger later on [in 2004]—we were really high on him. Aaron Rodgers the year after,” Polian said, via For The Win. “That’s the only name that comes to mind right away. And I don’t think there was a guy in between, but Tom Brady would have been a guy, and we were very high on him. Our guys really loved him, but we weren’t in the quarterback market, obviously. Those would be the guys I remember us giving solid, first-round, can-lead-you-to-a-championship grades.”
While it’s true the Colts weren’t looking for a quarterback in 2000, they still could’ve drafted one –– especially if they were so fond of Brady. Indianapolis’ final three picks in the 2000 NFL Draft –– center Matt Johnson, defensive tackle Rob Renes and cornerback Rodregis Brooks –– played a combined five games in the NFL. The Colts had a need for a backup QB in 2000 as well. According to the Football Database, the two pass-throwers behind Manning that season were Billy Joe Hobert and Kelly Holcomb. Indianapolis’ second-stringer quarterback in 2001, Brady’s first year as a starter, was 39-year-old Mark Rypien.
As the Patriots have shown over the last 15 years, it’s possible to draft a quarterback even if the No. 1 job isn’t open. They’ve selected eight QB’s since Brady took over under center, including Jimmy Garoppolo in the second round.
Considering Brady lasted until the Patriots took him with the No. 199 overall pick, it’s fair to surmise nobody was particularly high on him coming out of college. It’s laughable for Polian to say otherwise.
|Bill Polian: Tom Brady probably will win NFL MVP, but ‘if I had a vote it would be 10 votes for [Ezekiel] Elliott’||12.28.16 at 8:26 pm ET|
The NFL MVP race is coming down to the last week of the season and really any one of about five players could win the award, including Tom Brady.
Former Colts vice chairman and current ESPN NFL analyst Bill Polian went on ESPN Charlotte Radio Wednesday and said he believes Brady will win the award, but it didn’t seem like he agrees.
“I don’t know who is going to win. It’s usually a quarterback. It’s probably going to be Tom Brady if you asked me to guess, but if I had a vote it would be 10 votes for [Ezekiel] Elliott,” he said. “He’s made the Cowboys into a different team and all you have to do is look at the statistics of his backups when they play behind the same offense line, the same receivers and the same quarterback and look at the statistics when he is in the game. He is the difference makers of all difference makers. He’s the air apparent to AP [Adrian Peterson]. He’s the reason they are where they are.”
As for the AFC playoffs, he believes the Patriots have the advantage because they will likely be the No. 1 seed.
“I think New England, Pittsburgh and Kansas City are pretty close,” Polian said. “New England has the edge obviously because they are going to play at home and their record at home is beyond belief. That is an advantage for them. As you would say in tennis: Advantage Patriots.”
For more Patriots news, visit weei.com/patriots.
|Mike Florio on D&C: Broncos ‘going to want to move on once and for all’ from Peyton Manning after season||01.22.16 at 10:14 am ET|
Mike Florio of Pro Football Talk and NBC sports made his weekly appearance on Dennis & Callahan with Minihane on Friday morning to preview the AFC championship game. To hear the interview, go to the Dennis & Callahan audio on demand page.
With Manning vs. Brady XVII on the horizon, one of the big questions this week has been whether or not this will be Peyton Manning‘s final season in the league.
“If he had never come back and played, if November 15 against the Chiefs had been all we had seen of Manning this year, I think he would have been far more inclined to try to play next year to eliminate the whole Willie Mays stink that would have attached to him,” Florio said. “Just to come back and show, ‘I’m going out on my own terms, I can still play at a high level.’ But now I think it’s harder for him to play anywhere else next year, because he made it to the AFC championship game. And he came back and he acquitted himself well Week 17, and he played well enough to win last week. I mean, it wasn’t beautiful, but he played well enough to win. so I think it makes it harder for him to go somewhere else next year.
“I don’t think the Broncos want him in 2016. John Elway already is refusing to talk about it, they’re not going to want to pay him $19 million, they’re going to want to move on once and for all and find a guy that fits Gary Kubiak‘s system better. So I just think that the fact that he came back and played in two games and played well enough to advance to the AFC championship game is going to make it very hard for him to go somewhere where he doesn’t believe he can get as far or farther. And I can’t think of a team out there where he jumps right in and they’re immediately a final four team.”
“With Polian, it’s obvious. Polian drafted the guy. He’s hardly objective, he’s hated the Patriots for years, he lobbied for rule changes after the Patriots kicked the Colts’ butts in the playoffs back 10, 12 years ago. I don’t take anything Polian says on the topic with any degree of credibility,” Florio said. “How can he be credible on it? How can he be? … He obviously has a bias, and he should preface anything he says about Manning and Brady with that reality.”
|Bill Polian on MFB: Robert Kraft has ‘always been the NFL’s leading citizen’||05.22.15 at 12:20 pm ET|
ESPN NFL analyst Bill Polian, a frequent critic of the Patriots, joined the Middays with MFB crew on Friday to discuss Deflategate and how the Patriots are perceived around the NFL. To hear the interview, go to the MFB audio on demand page.
Polian, a former longtime Colts executive, had high praise for Robert Kraft, who this week announced the Patriots would not appeal their punishment for Deflategate.
“I think it’s just typical of Mr. Kraft. He’s always been the NFL’s leading citizen. He’s a leader in every way. He’s a guy who thinks about the league first, last and always,” Polian said. “Anybody else you might be a little bit surprised by the reaction, but knowing Mr. Kraft, I’m not surprised at all. He did what was best for the league rather than his own franchise.”
As for speculation that Kraft gave in to other owners, Polian said that’s unlikely due to the Patriots owner’s standing.
“No, I don’t think so. He’s one of the leading owners in the league. There’s no one going to pressure him,” Polian said. “The bottom line is he looked at the issues and recognized that while he probably would have liked things to turn out better for the Patriots in the long run, what’s important for the league is what ultimately counts. That attitude was called ‘league think,’ that phrase created, at least to my knowledge, by Pete Rozelle. And Mr. Kraft follows it to the letter.”
Polian said the issue is not about what did or did not happen, but whether the commissioner has the right to do what he did.
“It wasn’t about the argument,” Polian said. “At this point it isn’t about the Patriots or Tom Brady, even. It’s about the commissioner’s right to handle unilaterally — and in conjunction with the rights given him in the collective bargaining agreement since 1968, and tradition dating all the way back to the Black Sox in 1919, with Kenesaw Mountain Landis, the first commissioner of baseball. The commissioner has the right to handle the integrity of the game. It is his responsibility. And that responsibility extends not only to the owners and players and coaches and general managers and staff people, but to the fans as well. Because if the integrity of the game is called into question in any way, it affects the overall health of the game and standing of the game in society.
“So to take that from the commissioner is an absolutely bad precedent. And of course Round 2 of that takes place in Tom Brady‘s grievance hearing. But the fact that Mr. Kraft went ahead and accepted the commissioner’s decision is in line with the longstanding tradition of the league and is what is best for the league in the long run.”
|Bill Polian: ‘Obvious’ Patriots pushed for new extra-point rule because it would benefit them||05.20.15 at 9:20 pm ET|
Former Colts general manager Bill Polian, who pushed for a series of very specific changes to the pass interference rules as part of the competition committee after his Indy team was humiliated in the playoffs a decade ago, said Tuesday that it was “obvious” the Patriots proposed the changes in the extra-point rules for their own benefit.
Speaking with Sirius/XM Radio, Polian said the reason New England advocated pushing the PATs back to the 15-yard line was because it would give teams in “northern climes” an advantage late in the season.
“This was, in a different form, proposed by the New England Patriots. The reason they proposed it is obvious,” he said. “In January and December, and even in late November, in northern climes (like) Foxboro, Buffalo, Cleveland, Chicago, Pittsburgh — well documented, of course, in Pittsburgh at the open end of the stadium, how difficult it is to kick field goals. The team from the northern climes that plays and practices in the harsher weather — the old Meadowlands being a prime example of that — has a decided advantage. And they wouldn’t have proposed it if (the Patriots) didn’t think it would help them.”
Polian isn’t a fan of the new rules.
“This is emphasizing the kicking game at the most critical part, when really, the longstanding philosophy has been to de-emphasize the kicking game whenever possible,” said Polian, who currently works as an analyst for ESPN. “We want touchdowns rather than field goals.
“Somehow or other, as a traditionalist, as a guy who learned the game at the feet of Paul Brown, Jim Finks and Don Shula, I have a hard time getting my arms around this,” he added. “I worry about an AFC or NFC championship being decided on a missed field goal or a missed extra point from 32 yards in snow, on ice, in January. I think that’s a miscarriage of justice, if you will. I would’ve much preferred to see it stay where it was, because I didn’t see anything wrong with it.”
For more Patriots news, check out weei.com/patriots.
|Bill Polian: Lots to consider when it comes to shelling out top money for elite slot receivers||03.05.13 at 5:52 pm ET|
We have already written about how this is a key offseason for slot receivers, as many of them are either pending free agents or close to free agency and as a result, teams that have a top-level slot receiver across the league are looking at the Wes Welker situation as a potential contract that will set the bar for other elite slot guys like Victor Cruz, Danny Amendola and Percy Harvin.
On Tuesday afternoon, former NFL exec Bill Polian — who helped build the Bills, Panthers and Colts and is now an analyst for ESPN — was asked about any reservations GMs might have when it comes to paying top-level slot receivers like big-time receivers.
‘I don’t know that if there is any reservation about that other than injury and longevity. [Danny] Amendola has been injured. He’s a very good player, but you have to take the injuries into consideration,’ said Polian on a conference call with reporters. ‘That’s where it comes into play. I don’t think it’s necessarily small-bodied or even more quick than fast guys. They’re productive and have proven to be productive. I don’t think they come along every day. So I don’t think there is a glut of them on the market. In Wes’s case there is age and in Amendola’s case the injury so that plays into it.
‘[But] how much are you willing to commit to any individual player given your cap situation, a flat cap?’ he added. ‘It’s essentially a flat cap, and the ability to field the team within that flat cap. All of those things come into play. I don’t think it has to do with a specific position or a specific body type. Free agency is much more, much more about individuals, their productivity, their injury history, their age and their cost than the draft is. They’re almost diametrically opposed.’
|Bill Polian: Good draft for offensive line, linebacker and safety||02.23.13 at 1:46 pm ET|
INDIANAPOLIS — Bill Polian said this draft is well-stocked for a team looking to make additions at three different positions: offensive line, linebacker and safeties.
“This draft is a draft that I think is pretty good on the offensive line — I mean, throughout. Not just the first round. It’s pretty good on the offensive line,” said the former Colts GM at the scouting combine on Saturday afternoon. “I think there are some pretty good linebackers. I think there are some really good safeties. You probably would lean toward defense if you drew a line and said which side of the line this draft is heaviest on.”
Polian, who now works as an analyst for ESPN, said that while he’s not sure which direction the Patriots will go this year, he was impressed by what they did last spring when it came to restocking their defense with first-round picks Chandler Jones and Dont’a Hightower.
“I’m not sure which direction they’d go — they make that decision,” Polian said of New England, which holds the 29th overall pick in the draft. “They’ve done it well, making great use of all their picks — their multiple picks — to shore up the defense recently. They’ll make the right decision.”
Latest from Bleacher Report
- Biggest Needs New England Patriots Have Yet to Address This Offseason
- Super Bowl 49 Champion Bryan Stork Retires from NFL at 26 Years Old
- Tom Brady Super Bowl 51 Jersey Theft Timeline Revealed on Video
- Photos of Tom Brady's Previously Missing Super Bowl 51 Jersey Revealed
- New England Patriots: Updated Draft Big Board After First Wave of Free...
- Tyler Gaffney Released by New England Patriots
- Tom Brady Issues Statement on Recovery of Missing Super Bowl 51 Jersey